What CP531 means

The IRS describes CP531 as a first notice about backup withholding. The IRS says it is sent to tell you that you may be subject to backup withholding because of unreported or unpaid interest or dividend income.

Backup withholding means a payer would be told to withhold tax from your future interest and dividend payments to make sure the IRS receives the tax due on this income. The IRS says the current rate is 24 percent.

If you respond to the IRS notices and resolve the problem, backup withholding will not start.

Why you got it

Payers report interest and dividends to the IRS on Forms 1099-INT and 1099-DIV. IRC 3406(c)(2) describes the problem the IRS is looking for: either your return left out reportable interest or dividends, or you may have been required to file a return including them and didn't file.

The IRS's internal procedures call this the "C" program of backup withholding and list CP531 as one of the notices sent to the payee in that program.

What income this covers

The "C" program is limited to interest and dividends. IRC 3406(a)(2) says the underreporting trigger applies only to reportable interest or dividend payments, and IRC 3406(b)(2) defines those as payments required to be reported under the information return rules for interest, dividends, and patronage dividends. In plain terms, interest and dividends reported on Forms 1099-INT and 1099-DIV are generally covered. Patronage dividends on Form 1099-PATR count only when at least half the payment is in money.

How backup withholding gets triggered

IRC 3406(c)(1) requires all of the following before the IRS can notify your payers.

  • The IRS has determined there was underreporting.
  • At least 4 notices have been mailed to you over a period of at least 120 days about it.
  • If you filed a return for the year, the deficiency from the underreporting has been assessed.

The IRM describes the same structure in practice: you receive at least two notices from the return delinquency, balance due, underreporter, or examination process, plus two backup withholding notices, over at least 120 days. CP531 is one of those backup withholding notices.

What to do now

The IRS lists these steps.

  • File your Form 1040 if you haven't filed for the year.
  • Review the return you filed for interest or dividend income that was left out or understated.
  • Amend to report any underreported interest or dividends.
  • Pay the tax owed on that income.

The IRS suggests using its Tax Account tool to view your payoff amount and payment history or to order transcripts. A wage and income transcript shows data from information returns the IRS received, such as Forms 1099.

How to stop it, or keep it from starting

IRC 3406(c)(3) says the IRS will not start backup withholding, or will stop it, if it determines any of these.

  • There was no underreporting.
  • The underreporting has been corrected, and the tax, penalty, and interest have been paid.
  • Withholding has caused or would cause undue hardship, and future underreporting is unlikely.
  • There is a bona fide dispute about whether there was underreporting.

If the IRS has not yet notified your payers, it does not send the notice. If it already has, it gives you a written certification that withholding is to stop and notifies the payers.

The IRS says that to stop backup withholding, you need to correct the reason for it, such as by resolving the underreported income and paying the amount owed.

If you think the IRS is wrong

A bona fide dispute about whether there was underreporting is one of the statutory grounds for the IRS not to start withholding. The law provides that you may request that determination and may provide information with your request. Under IRS procedures for unfiled return cases, if you dispute backup withholding after a CP531, you are told to send a written request to one of the two centralized backup withholding campuses, in Kansas City or Philadelphia.

If you disagree, gather records that support your position before you respond.

Once backup withholding starts

The IRS says payers continue withholding until the IRS tells them to stop, or until you give them the IRS's written certification that you are no longer subject to it. Under IRS procedures, backup withholding normally ends at the end of the current year, but if you have not resolved the problem by October 15 of the current year, it continues through the following calendar year. Amounts withheld are credited against your tax for the year you received the income. Report the withholding shown on Form 1099 as federal income tax withheld on your return for that year.

What not to do

When you open a new account that will earn interest or dividends, you must certify that you are not subject to backup withholding due to previous underreporting.

Do not ignore related balance due or unfiled return issues, because you must satisfy all outstanding backup withholding related accounts to avoid backup withholding. An extension of time to pay or an installment agreement does not stop backup withholding, and if an installment agreement is granted, backup withholding continues until the account is paid in full.

A different kind of backup withholding

Backup withholding also happens when a payee fails to give a payer a correct taxpayer identification number, which is the "B" side of the program. That is a different issue with its own notices for payers, such as the CP2100. CP531 is about unreported or unpaid interest and dividend income, not a missing or incorrect number.