What this notice is
Letter 1125 is titled Transmittal of Examination Report. The manual calls Letter 1125 the 30 day letter that goes to a return preparer with an examination report and Pub 5 for appeal procedures. Letter 4858 is titled You may not have met your due diligence requirements. The manual says Letter 4858 is sent to EITC return preparers to alert them that they prepared questionable returns claiming certain tax benefits, and it explains the due diligence requirements and the consequences of preparing inaccurate returns in the future. These passages describe procedures for IRS employees, so your own letter controls on its exact terms.
Why you received it
The manual says Letter 1125 informs a preparer about a proposed penalty because the preparer did not attach Form 8867 as required under section 6695(g), and it includes Form 5816 and instructions. The manual says penalties under IRC 6694, 6695 and 6713 have pre-assessment appeal rights. Due diligence visits are described as the primary mechanism for proposing and assessing preparer penalties under IRC 6695(g). Each letter or notice to a preparer reminds them that not meeting due diligence requirements can result in a penalty assessed against the preparer.
Your deadline
Letter 1125 gives the preparer 30 days to respond. If there is no timely response to the letter, the manual says the penalty is assessed. In an unagreed case, the case goes into suspense for 30 days, during which the preparer may agree or protest. Use the date printed on your notice.
Your options
If the response is agreed or there is no response, the manual says the case is processed as an agreed case. In an agreed case, the preparer signs Form 5816. If the preparer submits a written pre-assessment protest within 30 days, the manual says the case file is reviewed for adequacy of the protest. The manual says the preparer should be given an opportunity to meet with the group manager to resolve the issues. Pre-assessment appeals consideration will be granted if requested for IRC 6694, IRC 6695 and IRC 6713 penalties. An unagreed preparer penalty case cannot go to Appeals for pre-assessment consideration if less than 365 days remain on the assessment statute, and Form 872-D is used to extend the statute.
What to gather
Read the whole notice, including any pages or forms that came with it. Letter 1125 is sent with Form 5816, Form 886-A, Pub 5 and Pub 594, so keep that whole package together. In a due diligence review, examiners look at proper completion of Form 8867, knowledge requirements, computation accuracy and record retention. Keep a copy of the notice and of everything you send to the IRS.
Where to get help
For Letter 4858, the manual says the IRS continues to monitor the preparer's future returns that claim the benefits subject to due diligence requirements. If you are not sure what the notice is asking for, call the IRS at the number printed on the notice. If you have a tax professional, give them a copy of the notice.