What this notice is

The IRS manual calls Letter 5123 the TFRP Agreement Secured closing letter and Letter 5124 the TFRP Not Sustained closing letter. It calls Letter 1536 the Closing Letter for Unagreed Employment Tax and Trust Fund Recovery Penalty. The manual describes the TFRP as a penalty against any responsible person required to collect, account for, and pay over taxes held in trust who willfully fails to perform any of these activities. The manual is written for Appeals employees, so it describes IRS procedure rather than the exact wording of each letter.

Why you received it

For an agreed case, the manual says Letter 5123 or Letter 5124 is used, and it covers pre-assessment appeals where the taxpayer signed Form 2751, Form 2751-AD or Form 866. For an unagreed case, the manual says Letter 1536 is used, and it covers pre-assessment appeals other than premature referrals where the taxpayer does not sign an agreement. The manual says Letter 5124 is used for unagreed, full concession cases because receiving Letter 1536 would be confusing to the taxpayer. An unagreed case includes protests considered withdrawn because the taxpayer failed to respond within 30 days to a request to perfect a defective protest or defective power of attorney.

Your deadline

Use the date printed on your notice. The manual says that in most cases the 60 day protest period allowed by Letter 1153 must be granted before the penalty is assessed. If a protest was not timely filed, the manual says the case is closed as a premature referral. For a premature referral, the manual says the taxpayer or power of attorney is told by telephone or letter that the case was returned to Collection and why.

Your options

If you disagree, gather records that support your position before you respond. For an agreed case, the manual says the closing letter includes an original copy of the agreement form. When a taxpayer protests only specific periods listed on Form 2751 and agrees with assessment of the others, the manual says Appeals releases jurisdiction on the periods not being appealed and Compliance will assess those taxes immediately and start collection action. The manual says Appeals is the sole function that may make the final administrative determination about the penalty.

What to gather

The manual lists checks the Appeals employee makes, including whether the protest was timely and valid and whether the power of attorney on Form 2848 is valid. It names Form 2751, Proposed Assessment of Trust Fund Recovery Penalty, as the form that lists the periods in a proposed assessment. Compare the notice with your own records for the same tax period. Keep a copy of the notice and of everything you send to the IRS. Write down the date you mailed your response and how you sent it.

Where to get help

The manual says that for an agreed case, the Appeals employee places the original agreement in the Collection file and sends an original copy to the Appeals Agreement Reviewer for storage. If you have a tax professional, give them a copy of the notice. Have the notice in front of you when you call. If you are not sure what the notice is asking for, call the IRS at the number printed on the notice.