What this notice is
Letter 286C is titled Minister's Waiver (4361) Disapproved. Letter 398C is titled Approval of Application for Exemption from: SE Tax (Form 4361). The same manual also uses Letter 398C when a Form 4029 is approved, under the title Approval of Application for Exemption from: FICA/Medicare Taxes (F4029). The manual passage is written for IRS employees, so it describes IRS procedure and not the exact wording of your letters.
Why you received it
The manual says a Form 4361 is disapproved when any of the five approval criteria are not met or when it was not submitted timely. When it is disapproved, the manual says a copy of the Form 4361 is returned to the taxpayer as an enclosure to Letter 286C. The manual also says Letter 286C is used to return the unprocessed Form 4361 if no response is received by the end of the Letter 287C suspense period. For a taxpayer who indicates membership in a religious order under a vow of poverty, the manual says to return the Form 4361 with Letter 286C and inform the applicant that they are automatically exempt from paying self-employment tax. The manual says that when all five criteria are met the application is approved, and a copy is returned to the taxpayer using Letter 398C.
Your deadline
Use the date printed on your notice. If the application was disapproved because it was filed late, the manual says to tell the taxpayer there are no appeal rights.
Your options
For a disapproval, the manual gives this example wording for Letter 286C: If you have any additional information you want us to consider, please submit a newly signed Form 4361, and include all supporting documentation relevant to your claim. The manual says the IRS may accept a timely filed letter in place of a timely filed Form 4361 if it contains all required information and the complete certification language that appears on Form 4361. For an approval, the manual says the taxpayer is instructed to retain the approval documentation indefinitely. Follow the instructions printed on your notice.
What to gather
Read the whole notice, including any pages or forms that came with it. Check that the name, taxpayer identification number, and tax period on the notice are yours. Compare the notice with your own records for the same tax period. Keep a copy of the notice and of everything you send to the IRS. If you disagree, gather records that support your position before you respond.
Where to get help
If you are not sure what the notice is asking for, call the IRS at the number printed on the notice. Have the notice in front of you when you call. If you have a tax professional, give them a copy of the notice.