What this notice is
Letter 31C is titled Duplicate Returns Filed; Explanation Requested. The manual says a multiple filing condition occurs when the same taxpayer identification number is used as the primary taxpayer on one return and as a secondary taxpayer on another return for the same tax year. The manual passages used here are instructions for IRS employees, so they describe IRS procedure and not the exact wording of your letter.
Why you received it
The manual tells telephone assistors to advise taxpayers to respond to Letter 31C. The manual says that when this filing condition occurs, the IRS posts the second return and freezes any overpayment on it. The manual says the letter is addressed only to the common taxpayer, who is the person found on both returns. The manual says the letter is issued to both addresses shown on the two returns when they are different. The manual says the letter is not sent when the case is re-categorized to another type of case.
Your deadline
The manual says the IRS suspends the case for 60 days after the letter, or 70 days for overseas taxpayers that meet international criteria. The manual also says that once taxpayers respond, they should hear something within 30 to 45 days. Use the date printed on your notice.
Your options
The manual says that if you reply that you filed both returns and the joint return is the correct one, the IRS backs out the other return when all of its income is reported on the joint return. The manual says the IRS then explains the action with Letter 673C, Duplicate Returns Filed; Adjustment or Refund Explained. The manual says that when some income from the other return was not reported on the joint return, the case goes to Exam for deficiency procedures instead. The manual says that if you tell the IRS you did not file one of the returns, two people may be using the same number and the case moves to identity theft. The manual says that when a Form 1040-X that resolves the issue arrives before the letter is mailed, the IRS uses it to adjust the account and does not send Letter 31C. The manual says the IRS may tell you a Form 1040-X must be filed if changes are needed to the joint return. The manual says that if you do not reply or do not sign the letter, the IRS compares the other return to the joint return to verify income and withholding. The manual says the IRS may then send a letter saying the filing status was changed due to information received and that a Form 1040-X may need to be filed. The manual says that if the taxpayer is due a refund, the IRS perfects the entity information if needed and releases the refund.
What to gather
The manual describes replies such as that the common taxpayer filed both returns, or has no knowledge of one of the returns.
Read the whole notice, including any pages or forms that came with it. Check that the name, taxpayer identification number, and tax period on the notice are yours. Compare the notice with your own records for the same tax period.
If you disagree, gather records that support your position before you respond. Keep a copy of the notice and of everything you send to the IRS.
Where to get help
If you are not sure what the notice is asking for, call the IRS at the number printed on the notice. Have the notice in front of you when you call. If you have a tax professional, give them a copy of the notice.