What this notice is

The manual says a Form 8233 that is either incorrect or incomplete is rejected and returned to the withholding agent with IDRS Letter 3383C or Letter 4071C. The manual says the IRS rejects the form with the 3383C or 4071C letter when there are errors that cannot be corrected, or the Form 8233 is incomplete. The manual says the beneficial owner of the income gives Form 8233 to the withholding agent. The manual passages used here are written for IRS employees, so they describe IRS procedure and not the exact wording of your letter.

Why you received it

The manual says the withholding agent determines the accuracy of the form and, if satisfied, accepts it by completing and signing the certification in Part IV of the form. It says that within 5 days after that, the withholding agent shall forward one copy of the form to the IRS. The manual says Form 8233 is valid for only one year. It says a form that is either incorrect or incomplete is the kind that gets rejected and returned.

Your deadline

The manual says the withholding agent has to wait a minimum of ten days before starting to withhold tax at the treaty rate reflected on the Form 8233 submitted by the foreign person. It says that if the IRS rejects Form 8233 after the minimum 10 day waiting period, the withholding agent, after receiving written information from the IRS, must withhold tax at the statutory rate of 30 percent. Use the date printed on your notice.

Your options

The manual says that upon receipt of the 3383C or 4071C and Form 8233, the withholding agent is responsible to begin withholding at the 30 percent statutory rate. It says this means the withholding agent must withhold tax on any payments made to the foreign person, both now and in the future, or until a corrected Form 8233 is received and approved by the IRS. The manual says Form 8233 must be provided to each withholding agent and generally with respect to each type of income. Follow the instructions printed on your notice. If you disagree, gather records that support your position before you respond.

What to gather

Read the whole notice, including any pages or forms that came with it. Check that the name, taxpayer identification number, and tax period on the notice are yours. The manual says tax examiners use the tax treaty tables on the IRS website for tax treaty information and Publication 519, Appendix A and B, for attachment requirements. Keep a copy of the notice and of everything you send to the IRS. Write down the date you mailed your response and how you sent it.

Where to get help

Have the notice in front of you when you call. If you are not sure what the notice is asking for, call the IRS at the number printed on the notice. If you have a tax professional, give them a copy of the notice.