What this notice is
Letter 3414C is titled Individual Requesting Repayment for a Refund Sent in Error. An erroneous refund is a refund you were not entitled to at all, or one larger than you were entitled to receive. The IRS can use this letter to request repayment, to follow up with interest, or to send a reminder of the balance.
Why you received it
The IRS believes a refund went out in error and has set up an erroneous refund case. One example in the manual is a payment misapplied to the wrong taxpayer number. You may get this letter after Letter 510C, which is treated as the first notice, if you did not respond within forty five days.
Your deadline
Use the date printed on your notice. IRS guidance on returning an erroneous refund says to return an uncashed check, or pay for a cashed one, no later than 21 days. If you did not cause the error and the refund was $50,000 or less, the first letter should say no interest is charged when you repay within twenty one calendar days of that letter. The IRS generally has two years to sue over this kind of refund, or five years when fraud or misrepresentation of a material fact is shown.
Your options
If you still hold an uncashed Treasury check, write Void on the back and return it with a short note explaining why. If the refund was deposited, contact your bank’s Automated Clearing House department and have it returned, and tell the IRS why it is coming back. If you need time, the manual says a monthly payment offer is accepted while the erroneous refund statute date is still open. A payment plan will not run past that date. If you disagree, gather records that support your position before you respond.
Some erroneous refunds, called Category D, can be recovered only by lawsuit, refund offset, or voluntary repayment, and not by a lien or levy. An unpaid balance can have a tax cost, because a final letter can warn that a Form 1099-C will be issued. Different procedures apply when a refund was issued to an identity thief.
What to gather
Gather your return, your bank statements, and any cashed or uncashed check so you can see what was received and why. When paying by check or money order, write Payment of Erroneous Refund, the tax period, the account type, and your taxpayer identification number on it. Keep the letter that shows any interest figure, because later letters can include updated interest. Keep a copy of the notice and of everything you send to the IRS.
Where to get help
If you are not sure what the notice is asking for, call the IRS at the number printed on the notice. If you have a tax professional, give them a copy of the notice. The Taxpayer Advocate Service has an online tool that can show whether it may be able to help with your issue.