What this notice is

The manual ties Letter 404C to Correspondence for Excess Social Security and Railroad Retirement Tax. Taxpayers report their excess social security and Tier 1 RRTA tax withheld on Schedule 3, Part II, line 11. The manual says Letter 404C is used to return original documents, and it can't be combined with other letters but must be used in addition to any other letter. These passages describe procedures for IRS employees, so your own letter controls on its exact wording.

Why you received it

To process an excess Social Security and RRTA claim, the individual taxpayer must report wages from more than one employer. Social Security or RRTA wages and tax withheld must exceed the maximum amount required for the tax year. For tax year 2025, the table lists maximum wages of $176,100 and maximum tax of $10,918.20. The credit is available only if the extra withholding is the result of the employee working for two or more employers. When excess Social Security was withheld by only one employer and there is one W-2, the manual points to Letter 404C. It points to Letter 404C when the taxpayer is married filing jointly and used earnings or Social Security from both spouses to calculate the excess.

Your deadline

Use the date printed on your notice. Follow the instructions printed on your notice.

Your options

The manual says a taxpayer can claim excess Social Security or RRTA Tier I tax when separate Forms W-2 have the same employer EIN and a parent company and one or more of its subsidiaries are responsible, or a company acted as an agent for more than one of the taxpayer's employers. A Professional Employer Organization or Certified Professional Employer Organization, a payroll processing company, will never reimburse the employee. If the wages don't exceed the wage base limit, the manual says the claim is disallowed with a fill-in saying: We disallowed your claim for excess Social Security withheld. That fill-in says you must have reported wages from more than one employer, your total wages must exceed the wage base limit, and the Social Security tax withheld must exceed the maximum amount required for the tax year. If you disagree, gather records that support your position before you respond.

What to gather

Social Security wages are found in Box 3 of the W-2 Form. The manual says to verify the overpayment of Social Security tax withheld based on Forms W-2. Keep a copy of the notice and of everything you send to the IRS.

Where to get help

The Taxpayer Advocate Service website offers a way to determine if TAS can help you with your tax issue. If you are not sure what the notice is asking for, call the IRS at the number printed on the notice.