What this notice is
Letter 4568 is titled Acknowledgement of Status of Final Accounting. Letter 5172 is titled Failure to Provide Final Accounting. Letter 5173 is titled Notification of Withholding Agent Ineligibility. The manual says the IRS issues Letter 4568 to the withholding agent reporting the results of the final accounting review. The manual passages used here are written for IRS employees, so they describe IRS procedure and not the exact wording of your letters.
Why you received it
The manual says the IRS must issue Letter 4568 on all cases within 60 calendar days of receipt of the final accounting budget, even if it finds no change in the budget or the withholding deposits. The manual says that if the final accounting is not received by the 60th day after the last event, overages are computed at the maximum potential amount and all expenses are disallowed. In that case, the manual says the IRS issues Letter 5172 and places the withholding agent on the ineligible list. The manual says Letter 5173 is used where there is a failure to submit the final accounting, and is issued along with Letter 5172.
Your deadline
Use the date printed on your notice. The manual says the IRS has 60 days from receipt of the final accounting budget to review it, request more support, negotiate in good faith, and issue Letter 4568. The manual says the IRS must receive supporting documentation during the 60 day negotiation period when the final accounting has been provided. The manual says that if the IRS does not receive documents for expense items, those expense items are computed at zero or up to the amount verified by documentation.
Your options
The manual says a withholding agent on the ineligible list can be reinstated. The manual says that to be reinstated, the agent must submit the final accounting or provide proof that it made the required deposits. The manual says that once those requirements are met, the agent must request reinstatement in writing to the program manager. The manual says Letter 5174, Reinstatement as Withholding Agent, is issued when the final accounting, support documentation and deposit have been submitted. The manual says that if a withholding agent is on the list, the representative may obtain a new withholding agent, or correct the problem and seek reinstatement.
What to gather
The manual says the IRS reviews the final accounting to check that only ordinary and necessary business expenses related to U.S. sourced personal service income for the current event or tour are present. The manual says that if settlement sheets are not received, overages are computed at the maximum potential amount. The manual says that if the IRS asked for supporting documents at signing, it also looks for proof of any additional withholding that was due. Compare the notice with your own records for the same tax period. Keep a copy of the notice and of everything you send to the IRS.
Where to get help
If you are not sure what the notice is asking for, call the IRS at the number printed on the notice. Have the notice in front of you when you call. If you have a tax professional, give them a copy of the notice.