What this notice is
Letter 4912, Tax Compliance Notice of Proposed Escalation, says the recipient is not in compliance with individual or business federal tax filing and payment obligations. It says the IRS proposes to escalate the case to the Office of Professional Responsibility. Letter 4912A, Proposing Denial of Participation into Annual Filing Season Program, says the recipient is not in compliance with personal federal tax filing and payment obligations. It says the IRS proposes to deny participation in that program. These letters concern the tax compliance of the practitioner who receives them, not the compliance of that practitioner's clients.
Why you received it
The IRS runs personal tax compliance checks as part of its return preparer suitability work. For Annual Filing Season Program participants, those checks apply to people who fail an initial automated tax compliance screening. To be considered compliant, a person must have filed all required personal and business returns and must also meet the IRS balance standard. In that process, Letter 4911-A comes first, and Letter 4912A follows if the issue is not resolved within 30 days of the earlier letter. The IRS lists Letter 4912 among its interim suitability letters.
Your deadline
Use the date printed on your notice. Follow the instructions printed on your notice. The due date matters because IRS next steps depend on whether you respond by it and whether its records show the issue was resolved. Even if you miss the date, a resolved issue can lead to Letter 5070 and closure of the case.
Your options
Find out exactly which returns or balances are the problem, because suitability analysts are not permitted to give detailed account information. If your response does not resolve the issue, the IRS may tell you to reach its customer service line to learn the exact problem. File any missing returns, and if you cannot pay a balance in full, pay as much as you can and review IRS payment options. Some conditions, such as a current year filing extension or a hardship status, can count as compliance or delay the case. If the problem remains, a case can be referred to the Office of Professional Responsibility when a credentialed preparer has failed to file two or more returns or has a qualifying unpaid balance. The Office of Professional Responsibility investigates and disciplines violations of Circular 230.
What to gather
Check that the name, taxpayer identification number, and tax period on the notice are yours. Gather copies of filed returns, proof of filing, proof of payments, and any payment arrangement for each year in question. Keep any Letter 4911-A or other earlier suitability letters with this one. Keep a copy of the notice and of everything you send to the IRS. Write down the date you mailed your response and how you sent it.
Where to get help
When the issue is resolved, the IRS sends Letter 5070, Notice of Resolution. If you are not sure what the notice is asking for, call the IRS at the number printed on the notice. The Taxpayer Advocate Service is an independent organization within the IRS, and it helps individuals, businesses, exempt organizations, and their representatives.