What this notice is
Letter 5025-F tells a preparer that an IRS review shows the preparer prepared inaccurate tax returns. The IRS manual describes it as a letter sent to preparers who may not have met their due diligence requirements. Letter 5138 is called a Return Preparer Client Audit Notification. The IRS manual says it is a pre-filing season letter that alerts preparers that some of their clients' returns will be audited. Letter 5364 is titled Missing Form 8867, Paid Preparer's Due Diligence. The IRS manual says it is sent when six of a preparer's client paper returns do not include Form 8867.
Why you received it
The Letter 5025-F sample says a review of your client tax returns shows they inaccurately claimed tax benefits and that you possibly failed your due diligence requirements. It adds that failure to perform such due diligence can result in penalties under Internal Revenue Code Section 6695(g). The Letter 5138 sample says the IRS is auditing some of your clients' returns that claimed the American Opportunity Tax Credit and the Earned Income Tax Credit. The IRS says it cannot supply details specific to the returns it is auditing. The Letter 5364 sample says a preparer must include Form 8867 with every paper tax return the preparer prepares. It lists Head of Household filing status, the Earned Income Tax Credit, the American Opportunity Tax Credit, and the Child Tax Credit family of credits.
Your deadline
The sample versions of Letter 5025-F, Letter 5138 and Letter 5364 each say you do not need to respond. The Letter 5025-F sample says it is for your information to ensure you are aware of the due diligence requirements and the potential consequences. Use the date printed on your notice.
Your options
The Letter 5025-F sample tells you to meet your specific due diligence requirements. It says to conduct an in-depth interview with every client each year and to apply a commonsense standard to the information your client provides. It also says to document the additional questions you ask and the client's response. The Letter 5025-F sample warns of a preparer audit and a penalty of $635 per failure to follow all due diligence requirements for each tax benefit per return. The Letter 5364 sample says a failure may result in a penalty of $560 per failure, with a maximum penalty of $2,240 per return. That sample tells you not to send the IRS a copy of any missing Forms 8867 and not to amend any returns to include them. The IRS says it will continue to monitor future returns you prepare that claim these benefits.
What to gather
Read the whole notice, including any pages or forms that came with it. The Letter 5364 sample says the IRS enclosed a list of the tax returns that were missing Form 8867 for you to review. Keep a copy of the notice and of everything you send to the IRS.
Where to get help
The sample letters point to Publication 4687, Paid Preparer Due Diligence. They also point to the preparer toolkit on IRS.gov, which includes a free Due Diligence Training and other resources. The sample letters say not to include personally identifiable information belonging to your clients in an email. If you are not sure what the notice is asking for, call the IRS at the number printed on the notice.