What this notice is

Letter 5170 is titled Important information about your IRS Direct Pay Payment. The manual says it explains that the payment attempted through Direct Pay was not successful and provides a description of the problem, followed by what to do next. It provides an error code. A second passage says that if a payment is returned or rejected, a letter 5170 is generated that explains the reason and provides resolution and resubmission information to avoid penalties and interest accrual. These passages describe procedures for IRS employees, so your own letter controls on its exact wording.

Why you received it

The manual says the letter states that the rejected payment may result in penalty and interest, and if so, a separate letter will follow with the specific details. For error code R01, the return reason is insufficient funds, and the next step is to resubmit your payment and ensure you have sufficient funds in your account. For error code R02, the return reason is account closed, and the next step is to resubmit your payment and ensure you enter a valid checking or savings account number. For error code R08, the payment was stopped, and the manual says the IRS was unable to process the previous payment due to a stop payment request. For error code R13, the routing number was invalid, and the next step is to resubmit your payment with a valid routing number for your financial institution. For error codes such as R10 and R16, the manual says the taxpayer was advised to contact their financial institution.

Your deadline

The manual says that if a payment, including an installment agreement payment, was submitted on or before the due date and a confirmation number was received, the payment will be considered timely. It says the letter advises that the best way to avoid or reduce penalty is to immediately replace the payment. Applicable penalties and interest will continue to accrue on unpaid balances until paid in full. Use the date printed on your notice.

Your options

In rare cases, the manual says the IRS may consider abating penalties resulting from an unsuccessful Direct Pay payment. It gives the example of a taxpayer who accidentally inputs the routing number into the payment amount field. In all other cases, the manual says normal penalty relief procedures apply. Section 6404(a) gives the IRS authority to abate at any time the unpaid portion of any liability that is excessive in amount, or that is erroneously or illegally assessed. If an installment agreement erroneously defaulted because of an unsuccessful Direct Pay payment, the manual points to its guidance on revision and reinstatement of installment agreements. If you disagree, gather records that support your position before you respond.

What to gather

For a new Direct Pay payment, the manual says the user enters the amount of payment, the date of payment within 30 days, and bank account information including routing number, account number and type of bank account. The user must use the exact information from the return they are using to verify their identity, such as name, address and filing status. Keep a copy of the notice and of everything you send to the IRS.

Where to get help

The manual says a link for IRS Direct Pay can be found on the Pay tab of the IRS.gov home page. The Taxpayer Advocate Service website offers a way to determine if TAS can help you with your tax issue. If you are not sure what the notice is asking for, call the IRS at the number printed on the notice.