What this notice is
Letter 5180 tells a person that a Collection Appeals Program, or CAP, appeal is being returned to Collection as premature, and it gives the reason. Letter 2421 acknowledges an administrative appeal of a Notice of Federal Tax Lien and gives a contact point for questions. Either letter may go to the person who appealed, and Letter 5180 can even go to a third party.
Why you received it
Appeals can treat a CAP case as premature if the appeal came too early, the required manager meeting did not happen, the issue is excluded, or the appeal is late. Letter 2421 appears in the manual where a lien appeal that questions the validity of an assessment is referred to Examination.
Your deadline
Use the date printed on your notice. For a field CAP request, you should tell Collection within 2 business days after the manager conference that you plan to appeal, and Form 9423 must be postmarked within 3 business days after it. A lien appeal claiming an erroneous filing must be made within one year after the taxpayer becomes aware of the filing. After a referral, Examination has thirty calendar days to return its decision on the assessment.
Your options
After Letter 5180, fix the problem it names if you can, such as requesting the manager conference. If your concern is a levy on property you say is yours, the IRS may direct you to a wrongful levy claim under Publication 4528. That claim generally must be made within 2 years of delivery of the levy notice when cash was or will be turned over. The manual says collection action is suspended while lien, levy, and seizure CAP cases are in Appeals, so ask Collection about current status once a case is returned.
After Letter 2421, remember that this process cannot be used to challenge the underlying deficiency, and use the contact point in the letter for questions. If the lien filing was erroneous, the IRS must issue a certificate of release, when practical within 14 calendar days of that decision.
What to gather
For a CAP issue, gather Form 9423 if you used it, notes from your manager conference, and an explanation of what you disagree with and how you propose to resolve it. For a lien appeal, the request must be in writing and include your name, current address, taxpayer number, the grounds, and a copy of the lien notice if available. If you claim the debt was already satisfied, include the canceled check or other proof of payment. Keep a copy of the notice and of everything you send to the IRS.
Where to get help
IRS collection appeal guidance says you may represent yourself or use an attorney, certified public accountant, or a person enrolled to practice before the IRS. If you have a tax professional, give them a copy of the notice. The Taxpayer Advocate Service has an online tool that can show whether it may be able to help with your issue.