What this notice is
Letter 5351 is titled VCP Request a Taxpayer Signed Compliance Statement. The manual describes it as a cover letter used when the compliance statement must be signed by the plan sponsor. Letter 5336 is titled Disclosure Request for Anonymous VCP, and the manual describes it as a cover letter to the representative requesting the plan sponsor's identity. The manual describes a compliance statement as generally a written agreement between the IRS and a plan sponsor that results from a successful VCP submission. These passages come from IRM 7.2.2, an IRS manual of procedures, so your own letter controls on its exact wording.
Why you received it
The manual says Letter 5351 is used when there is a material change in the VCP narrative affecting failures and correction and a new penalty of perjury statement has not been secured. It also says the IRS uses Letter 5351 when the traditional or streamlined compliance statement is to be signed by the plan sponsor. The manual says to use Letter 5336 to request the applicant and plan identity for anonymous VCP submissions. It says the IRS makes that request once there is full agreement with the representative, and it names Letter 5336 for this purpose. The anonymous submissions in that passage are those made to the IRS before 12/31/2021.
Your deadline
The manual says the response time for a Letter 5351 is generally 30 days. It says the specialist may use a shorter timeframe, such as 15 or 21 days, in appropriate circumstances. It also says specialists must give a 30 day response period if the applicant or their representative later asks for it. Use the date printed on your notice.
Your options
The manual says the taxpayer or representative may fax the disclosure information and other necessary documents. It says that after disclosure the IRS runs a check to confirm that the plan sponsor and plan are not under examination. If you disagree, gather records that support your position before you respond.
What to gather
For disclosure, the manual lists the EIN, the name of the plan sponsor, the name of the plan, and the plan number. Keep a copy of the notice and of everything you send to the IRS. Write down the date you mailed your response and how you sent it.
Where to get help
If you are not sure what the notice is asking for, call the IRS at the number printed on the notice. Have the notice in front of you when you call.