What this notice is
Letter 5365 is titled Incomplete Form 8809, and Letter 5381 is titled Extension Request Denied Form 8809. Form 8809 is the Application for Extension of Time to File Information Returns. Letter 5378 is titled Recipient Copy Approved, and Letter 5379 is titled Extension Request Denied - Recipient Copy. Letters 5378 and 5379 relate to recipient extension requests, which may be submitted by filing Form 15397, Application for Extension of Time to Furnish Recipient Statements. These passages describe procedures for IRS employees, so your own letter controls on its exact wording.
Why you received it
The manual says Letter 5381, Extension Request Denied, is issued for late extension requests. It says Letter 5365 for an incomplete Form 8809 is issued to the taxpayer. Forms in the W-2 series, except Form W-2G, and Forms 1099-NEC are not eligible for an automatic 30-day extension. Those forms are only allowed a single 30-day non-automatic extension of time to file. For that extension, Form 8809 must be submitted on paper with the appropriate check box on Line 7 completed. Form 8809 must be signed by the filer or transmitter, or a person who is duly authorized to sign a return.
Your deadline
The manual says the request must be postmarked by January 31st in the calendar year the tax year is being processed. For Letter 5365, the manual says the letter advises the taxpayer, payer or filer to respond within 20 days from the date of the letter and to write Reconsideration at the top of Form 8809 when responding. A recipient extension request must be submitted no later than the date the statements are due to the recipients. Use the date printed on your notice.
Your options
An automatic 30-day extension to file information returns may be requested by mailing Form 8809 to the Ogden Service Center address provided in the Form 8809 Instructions. The manual says approval letters will not be issued for that extension, and incomplete and denied letters are issued when warranted. Recipient extension requests can be submitted via fax or by using the mobile-friendly forms option at IRS.gov. If you are not sure what the notice is asking for, call the IRS at the number printed on the notice.
What to gather
The manual says required information for a recipient extension request includes the filer or employer name, TIN, address, a statement that the request is to provide statements to recipients, the type of return, the reason for delay, and the signature of the payer or a duly authorized person. Generally, only the payer may sign the letter requesting the extension for recipient copies. Keep a copy of the notice and of everything you send to the IRS.
Where to get help
The Taxpayer Advocate Service is an independent organization within the IRS, led by the National Taxpayer Advocate, that helps taxpayers and protects taxpayer rights. TAS offers free help when a tax problem is causing a financial difficulty, or when you have tried and been unable to resolve your issue with the IRS. If you have a tax professional, give them a copy of the notice.