What this notice is
Letter 5544 is called the Technically Incomplete Letter, and the manual says it is sent with List of Missing Items pages. The manual describes Letter 5544 as a request for additional information after the Technical Review. Letter 5888 is described as a Failure to Respond letter for cases under Rev. Proc. 2016-37.
These descriptions come from a manual written for IRS employees, so they describe IRS procedure and not the exact wording of your letter.
Why you received it
The manual says the IRS sends Letter 5544 if it does not receive a complete response to Letters 1196, 1955, 5537, or 5542 by the next business day after the letter deadline and the case does not meet the requirements for a closing agreement. Letter 5888 is for applications where the sponsor does not provide a timely and complete response to Letter 5544.
Your deadline
The manual tells the IRS to insert a response date 30 calendar days from the date of the Letter 5544. If that date falls on a Saturday, Sunday, or legal holiday, the manual says the next business day is used. Use the date printed on your notice.
Your options
If the applicant sends a deficient response to Letter 5544 before the deadline, the manual says the IRS immediately calls to notify them of the deficiencies. The manual says the call explains that unless the missing information is sent by the deadline, the case will be closed as an incomplete application. If a complete response is not sent by the due date, the manual says the IRS closes the case as incomplete and issues Letter 5888 with the List of Missing Items. When Letter 5888 is issued, the user fee is generally not refunded, though overpayments and refunds due to user fee exemption eligibility will be refunded. A phone procedure in the manual says the sponsor or power of attorney would have been given 30 days to resubmit the application, with a new user fee required. Follow the instructions printed on your notice.
What to gather
Gather what the List of Missing Items names, because the manual says that list is attached to Letter 5544. The manual says that if the plan sponsor has an authorized representative, the letters are also sent to the representative using Letter 937-A. Read the whole notice, including any pages or forms that came with it. Check that the name, taxpayer identification number, and tax period on the notice are yours. Keep a copy of the notice and of everything you send to the IRS. Write down the date you mailed your response and how you sent it.
Where to get help
The manual says the IRS instructs callers to contact the EP Correspondence Unit when the date on irs.gov has passed. If you are not sure what the notice is asking for, call the IRS at the number printed on the notice. Have the notice in front of you when you call. If you have a tax professional, give them a copy of the notice.