What this notice is

Letter 5887C is titled Notification of Preliminary Action Regarding Chapter 3 or Chapter 4 Withholdings Shown as Payments on Your Tax Return. The manual says it advises that the IRS is holding the part of the refund that relates to the withholding credit claimed on line 25g of Form 1040-NR while it reviews it. Letter 5904C is titled Notification of Preliminary Claim Disallowance Regarding Chapter 3 or 4 Withholding. The manual says it also advises the taxpayer to contact their withholding agent and that it will specify all reasons for the mismatch. These passages describe procedures for IRS employees, so your own letter controls on its exact terms.

Why you received it

The manual says that when the matching program identifies a credit that requires further research, a freeze is placed on the account. Letter 5904C is issued when the matching program indicates that a Form 1042-S does not match. One mismatch the manual describes is when the total tax withheld shown by all withholding agents does not match the total credits claimed on Form 1040-NR. The letter advises that the IRS reduced or eliminated the amount on line 25g of Form 1040-NR because the Form 1042-S information did not match what withholding agents filed.

Your deadline

The manual says Letter 5887C tells the taxpayer they do not need to do anything at this time. It says the review can take up to six months from the date the return was received, the due date of the return, or the correspondence received date, whichever is later. The manual also describes a 154 day freeze that begins from the latest of the return received date, the return due date, or the correspondence received date. Use the date printed on your notice.

Your options

When the review is finished, the manual says the IRS will either send the refund, deny it in full, or send a portion of it. If the freeze period has expired and the credit is still frozen, staff tell the taxpayer the concern is being elevated and that they should hear from the IRS in 6 to 8 weeks. For Letter 5904C, the taxpayer and the withholding agent need to work out the reason for the mismatch, and the withholding agent may need to file an accurate Form 1042-S and give the taxpayer a corrected copy. If the withholding agent never gave the IRS Copy A of Form 1042-S, the taxpayer must follow up with the withholding agent.

What to gather

Read the whole notice, including any pages or forms that came with it. Gather your Forms 1042-S from each withholding agent and compare them with the withholding credit you claimed on line 25g of Form 1040-NR. A letter from the United States Competent Authority is acceptable proof of withholding in place of Form 1042-S if it has a signature and states the withholding amount allowed and the correct tax year. Keep a copy of the notice and of everything you send to the IRS.

Where to get help

If a taxpayer says they are a victim of identity theft, the manual says staff follow the identity theft procedures. If you are not sure what the notice is asking for, call the IRS at the number printed on the notice. If you have a tax professional, give them a copy of the notice.