What this notice is

Letter 5918 is called Protest Received Rebuttal and Transfer to Appeals. The manual says it is used to send the rebuttal to the taxpayer, and to the power of attorney if applicable. It says the rebuttal is sent with the rebuttal to the protest on a Form 886-A, or with a revised RAR. The manual tells staff to make sure the updated RAR states that the revised RAR supersedes the previously provided RAR. The manual describes steps IRS staff follow, so your own letter controls on its exact terms.

Why you received it

The manual says that when a taxpayer or power of attorney files a valid timely protest to the issues in a 30-day letter, staff evaluate any new facts or arguments and prepare a revised report rebutting them if applicable. The manual says an organization has 30 days to agree or protest a proposal, and that a rebuttal Letter 5918 is issued if a written protest does not change the IRS position. If the protest does not change the original conclusion, staff review the protest letter to ensure it is a valid protest per Pub 5. For a tax exempt organization that disagrees but provides no new information, or information that does not change the report, the manual says a Letter 5918 rebuttal is issued to the organization. If the information decreases the tax, the manual says a corrected report only is issued, with no new 30-day letter, and Letter 5918 covers the part of the deficiency that remains unchanged.

Your deadline

For tax exempt bond cases, the manual says the rebuttal is mailed to the issuer, but the issuer is not given an opportunity to respond to the rebuttal. In a refund claim case, the manual says the signed letter is mailed with the rebuttal and informs the issuer that the refund claim was forwarded to Appeals. Use the date printed on your notice.

Your options

If the protest contains new information or analysis, the manual says the issuer is notified that the new information may change the case's outcome and requires further review and possible discussions before the case file is transferred to Appeals. The manual says the rebuttal addresses only statements, facts or arguments that were not completely addressed in the 30-day letter, plus new arguments or facts. An appeal request must meet the requirements of Rev. Proc. 2006-40 and Pub 5. If a request does not meet the requirements, the manual says staff call the issuer or authorized representative and allow up to 30 days to perfect the request. If you disagree, gather records that support your position before you respond.

What to gather

Keep your protest and the 30-day letter, because the manual says the case file contains the dated 30-day letter, the taxpayer's valid protest letter and the revised report. For a tax exempt bond issuer, the manual says the case file contains Letter 4413, the Notice of Proposed Adverse Determination, a valid protest and Letter 5918. Read the whole notice, including any pages or forms that came with it. Check that the name, taxpayer identification number, and tax period on the notice are yours. Keep a copy of the notice and of everything you send to the IRS. Write down the date you mailed your response and how you sent it.

Where to get help

If you are not sure what the notice is asking for, call the IRS at the number printed on the notice. Have the notice in front of you when you call. If you have a tax professional, give them a copy of the notice. The IRS says taxpayers have the right to retain an authorized representative of their choice to represent them in their dealings with the IRS. It also says taxpayers have the right to seek assistance from a Low Income Taxpayer Clinic if they cannot afford representation. The Taxpayer Advocate Service describes itself as an independent organization within the IRS. It says its job is to strive to ensure that every taxpayer is treated fairly and knows and understands their rights.