What a math error notice is

Section 6213(b) of the tax code covers assessments arising out of mathematical or clerical errors on a return.

A math error notice is not a notice of deficiency, and you cannot file a Tax Court petition based on it.

The usual rule that the IRS cannot assess tax until a notice of deficiency has been mailed does not stop a math error assessment.

In math error cases, the IRS may assess additional tax and decrease a credit by setting a math error.

By law, a math error notice must state the error the IRS alleges and explain it.

What counts as a math error

The law defines a mathematical or clerical error to include an error in addition, subtraction, multiplication, or division shown on any return.

It also includes an entry on a return that is inconsistent with another entry on the same return. It includes an omission of information that is required to be supplied on the return to substantiate an entry on the return.

The definition also includes a deduction or credit entered in an amount that exceeds a statutory limit, when the items needed to apply that limit appear on the return.

The definition also covers certain missing taxpayer identification numbers, such as an omission of a correct TIN required for the earned income credit or the child tax credit.

CP11, CP12, CP13 and CP16

An IRS reference that lists computer paragraph (CP) notice numbers describes CP11, CP12, CP13 and CP16 as math error notices.

A CP11 notice means the IRS corrected one or more mistakes on your tax return. Because of those corrections, the amount you owe has changed.

A CP12 notice means the IRS corrected one or more mistakes on your tax return. As a result, you are now either due a refund or your original refund amount has changed.

A CP13 notice means the IRS corrected one or more mistakes on your tax return. Because of these changes, you are not due a refund and you do not owe an additional amount.

A CP16 notice means the IRS corrected one or more mistakes on your tax return. Because you or your spouse owe other tax debts, the IRS applied all or part of your refund to pay off those debts.

On CP11, CP12 and CP13 notices, the "What we changed on your return" section shows what caused the change.

Asking for abatement within 60 days

When a math error notice says an assessment of tax has been or will be made, the law lets you file a request for abatement of that assessment within 60 days after the notice is sent.

If you ask for abatement of a math error assessment within 60 days, the IRS must abate it, with or without supporting documents. IRS procedures say an abatement request may be written or oral.

If you send the request by U.S. mail, IRS procedures use the postmark date to decide whether it was on time.

The law bars a levy or court proceeding to collect a math error assessment during the period in which it may be abated.

What happens after abatement

Any reassessment of the abated tax is subject to the deficiency procedures.

When you disagree but do not send supporting documents, IRS procedures say staff should explain the consequences of abatement, which can include a referral of the case to Examination and a held refund.

When an abatement request comes without supporting documents, IRS procedures refer the case to Exam Classification, and if you disagree with its determination, you can appeal before a notice of deficiency is issued. If a notice of deficiency is issued, you have the opportunity to file a petition with the United States Tax Court.

Dates on the notice

The IRS pages for CP11, CP12, CP13 and CP16 say that if you don't contact the IRS by the date shown on your notice, you will lose formal rights to have the changes reversed and your right to appeal to the U.S. Tax Court. If you contact the IRS and send supporting documents after the date shown on your notice, the IRS will consider them and may reverse the changes if it agrees with you.

Under IRS procedures, if you ask for abatement within 60 days, the IRS must abate the assessment, and the law says any reassessment must then follow the deficiency procedures. If a notice of deficiency is then issued, you have the opportunity to file a petition with the United States Tax Court.

If no abatement request was made within the 60 days and the math error creates a balance that goes into a collection process, you may still contest it under the collection due process procedures.

For a CP11, if you agree with the changes, pay the amount owed by the date shown on your notice. For a CP12, if you agree with the changes, no response is required.

Sources