What this notice is
The IRS manual lists Letter 2809C as the Withholding Compliance release of lock-in letter to the employer. It lists Letter 4074C as the reply to an employer's inability to change an automated Form W-4 system. The manual says an employer must honor a valid withholding certificate from an employee until the IRS gives written notice to disregard it, which it calls a lock-in letter. It says Letter 2800C tells the employer to disregard the Form W-4 submitted by the taxpayer and to withhold at the filing status and withholding rate determined by the IRS. These passages describe IRS procedure for employees rather than the wording of each letter.
Why you received it
The manual says the IRS issues Letter 2809C to the employer and Letter 2813C to the taxpayer when it releases a lock-in. Its list of release situations includes a taxpayer who was erroneously locked in, a taxpayer who is not subject to withholding, and a taxpayer with a pending or approved Offer in Compromise. The manual also says to offer release to taxpayers who are tax compliant with all filing and payment requirements for the three tax years ending with the most recent return due. The manual says that if a taxpayer says the employer will not honor a Form W-4 that results in more income tax withholding than the modification letter specified, the IRS sends Letter 4074C to the employer.
Your deadline
Use the date printed on your notice. For the original lock-in, the manual says Letter 2800C requires the employer to wait 60 days before adjusting the employee's withholding to the status and rate in that letter. The manual states that the earliest a lock-in letter may be effective is 45 calendar days after the date of the letter.
Your options
The manual says the employer must withhold at the status and rate in the IRS notice, but it must honor a Form W-4 that results in more income tax withholding than the notice specifies. It says employers must submit copies of effective withholding certificates only if directed to do so in a written notice to the employer or under published guidance. For an employee who is not working for the employer on the date of the notice, the manual says regulations require the employer to furnish the employee's copy of the lock-in letter if the employer reasonably expects the employee to resume work within 12 months. If an employer calls to verify a modification, the manual says the IRS gives only the modified status and rate and the amount of any annual reduction or additional amount per pay period, and does not discuss Form W-4 calculations or case selection criteria.
What to gather
The manual says that when an employer calls, the IRS asks for the name and Social Security Number of the taxpayer to which the call relates, so have those ready. If an employer needs a copy of the lock-in letter, the manual says the IRS determines whether the lock-in has occurred and whether the employer just lost the original and needs a copy for its records. Compare the notice with your own records for the same tax period. Keep a copy of the notice and of everything you send to the IRS. Write down the date you mailed your response and how you sent it.
Where to get help
The manual lists Publication 15, Employer's Tax Guide, and Publication 15-T, Federal Income Tax Withholding Methods, among the publications used in the program. It also lists a WHC Employer Withholding Assistant among the program tools. If you have a tax professional, give them a copy of the notice. Have the notice in front of you when you call. If you are not sure what the notice is asking for, call the IRS at the number printed on the notice.