What this notice is

Letter 5072 is titled Examiner's Rebuttal. The manual says examiners use it to transmit a rebuttal to the taxpayer. A Letter 5072 rebuttal is prepared on Form 886-A, according to the manual. Another section says Letter 5072 is used as a cover for the rebuttal. The manual passages used here tell IRS employees what to do, so they describe IRS procedure and not the exact wording of your letter.

Why you received it

The manual says that if the originating function prepares a rebuttal to a taxpayer's protest, it must be shared with the taxpayer or representative when the file is sent to Appeals. It says the rebuttal covers statements, facts and arguments not previously addressed in the examination report, new arguments or facts raised by the taxpayer, and factual differences between the report and the protest. The manual says a copy of the rebuttal must be provided to the taxpayer at the time the case is sent to Appeals. For excise cases, it says that if no rebuttal is prepared, Letter 2280-X, Transfer to Appeals, tells the taxpayer the case is being closed to Appeals. In a passage about a rejected offer, the manual says a rebuttal to the protest goes to the taxpayer with Letter 5072 instead of Letter 2280. In a section on partnership audits, the manual lists Letter 5072 as an example of how the examiner's rebuttal is sent. For tax exempt and government entity cases, the manual says to use Letter 5918 instead.

Your deadline

The manual says actions on a protest, including rebutting it, should be completed within 20 days of receipt of the protest unless the case needs more development. For excise cases, it says a protest is generally reviewed within seven calendar days of receipt. If a protest is not adequate, the manual says Letter 1025 allows the taxpayer ten days to provide an adequate protest. Use the date printed on your notice.

Your options

The manual says all excise cases are eligible for an Appeals conference if the taxpayer submits an adequate written protest, when required, or a small case request. It says to be adequate, a written protest must comply with Publication 5, Your Appeal Rights and How to Prepare a Protest if you Disagree. It says a protest that does not comply should be returned and additional time granted to perfect it. The manual says that if the taxpayer submits new information or raises a new issue Examination has not considered, the case will generally be returned to Examination. It says Appeals gives the originating function the chance to review and comment on significant new information presented during the Appeals proceedings. Follow the instructions printed on your notice.

What to gather

The manual says Letter 5072 with the attached rebuttal is included with the taxpayer's protest in the case file. Read the whole notice, including any pages or forms that came with it. Compare the notice with your own records for the same tax period. If you disagree, gather records that support your position before you respond. Keep a copy of the notice and of everything you send to the IRS.

Where to get help

The manual says the Taxpayer Advocate Service may be of assistance to taxpayers experiencing economic harm who are seeking help resolving tax problems that normal procedures have not resolved. If you are not sure what the notice is asking for, call the IRS at the number printed on the notice. Have the notice in front of you when you call. If you have a tax professional, give them a copy of the notice.